Send to Friend

FromTo


Blog Entry from The Daily Gotham

Europe's Yarmulke Ban

As far as I know there is no European yarmulke-specific ban. But there are numerous headscarf, burqa and veil bans in place or under consideration.

Yesterday I saw a pod on Current TV about Britain's consideration of a headscarf ban, pushed by politicians like Jack Straw. It wasn't the most detailed of their segments, but it showed some of the deep xenophobia behind this movement. As a side note, for those who haven't watched Current TV, they have some very powerful stuff. They filmed in North Korea, revealing how seriously weird and screwed up that place is and showing a wry humor in the process. Their earlier coverage of Haiti was excellent. Their coverage of the Iraq and Afghan wars from the point of view of both our soldiers and the citizens of those nations has sometimes been extraordinary. They have some crap, but some of their stuff is well worth watching.

Back to the headscarf ban.

In France a ban on Muslim headscarves and other "conspicuous" religious symbols at state schools has been in place since 2004. I don't like their law, but it has one advantage of including all "conspicuous" religious symbols. My question is has it been equally enforced? Have Jews been prevented from wearing their Yarmulkes openly? What about crucifixes?

Some German states have headsarf-specific bans, preventing school teachers from wearing them. One wonders world reaction had they made it a yarmulke-specific ban!

In Italy, some local politicians have been sneaky and used antique anti-mask laws to target people wearing burqas. There is some legitimacy to this approach because the focus is on anything that hides the face. One can argue that it shouldn't be illegal to hide one's face (Joseph Merrick might have objected to such laws), but if enforced equally, there is at least a facade of not targeting Muslims.

But now Britain seems to be considering one of the most xenophobic and unfair ban. Jack Straw proposed a Muslim headscarf ban because the wearing of such clothing "harmed community relations." Of course advocating the banning of such clothing ALSO harms community relations, but I have yet to hear anyone advocate the banning of Jack Straw. In fact many British newspapers and politicians are backing Jack Straw's proposed ban on headscarves.

In the CurrentTV pod many of those interviewed supported the ban specifically because the wearing of headscarves is different and therefore separates those people from "normal" society. Of course the same could be said of yarmulkes, crucifixes and the like. Or punk clothing. Or just about anything that so-called "normal" people feel threatened by.

Now I personally find a religious requirement for women to cover themselves up offensive and sexist. But I find it even more offensive to ban a method of dress simply because it is perceived as not "normal," which in this case means not conforming to the majority tastes. Isn't one of the foundations of Western democracy that we have rights to define ourselves as individuals, not merely as members of the dominant culture? What forms of dressing differently are acceptable and what forms aren't? Should Jack Straw be calling for a yarmulke, turban and crucifix ban as well since Jews, Sikhs and Catholics are also minorities in Britain?

I see no reasonable purpose behind most of these bans except to harass Muslims.

Meanwhile, here in the United States, our first Muslim congressman, Keith Ellison, is being sworn in using a Q'ran once owned by Thomas Jefferson. We, of course, have our own crazy xenophobes like Virginia Republican Virgil Goode who claims that if Kieth Ellison is allowed to do this we may see the very fabric of our culture dissolve. Personally I have more faith in the robustness of our culture and the benefits of diversity than the very frightened Goode seems to. I welcome Keith Ellison, Q'ran and all. And I think it says something very promising about America that he is being sworn in with Thomas Jefferson's Q'ran! A Muslim being sworn in using a Q'ran owned by one of America's atheist Founding Fathers really kicks butt.

mole333's picture

| | | | | |

brought to you by


Current weather

NY - New York City, Central Park

day-clear
  • Clear sky
  • Temperature: 35.6 °F
  • Wind: Variable from Southeast to West, 9.2 mph, gusts up to 17.3 mph
  • Pressure: 29.43 inHg
  • Rel. Humidity: 64%
  • Visibility: 10 miles

Premium Advertisers


Fill up our coffee cup fund!






Visit Our Sponsors


Subscribe to our daily digest

In keeping with the "city that never sleeps" tradition, keep up to date with our daily syndication digest.



Powered by FeedBlitz


culturekitchen Media

The Publisher
Liza Sabater

Fresh dissent served daily
culturekitchen

Grassroots News and
Activism for New Yorkers

Daily Gotham

Feminist Bloggers Network
BlogSheroes

A new kind of voyeurism
Voogling

Art + Code + Philosophy
Potatoland.blog

Got any dirt, tips, leads or money for us? Then drop us a line or two at editors [at] dailygotham [dot] com or use our general contact form to reach everybody in the editorial team ASAP.


Only in New York

Just as dispiriting, party regulars chose as the convicted Norman's successor Assemblyman Vito Lopez, an old-time ward heeler from Bushwick who has never shown a zeal for reform until, gee whiz, now. He vows the party will consult a panel of learned men and women, such as Brooklyn Law School's dean, about picking quality judges.

We've seen this movie before, and the ending stinks. Two years ago, Norman and party district leaders, Lopez included, pledged they would never support a candidate for a judgeship who had not been approved by an independent screening commission. This year, for the first time, the panel reviewed Civil Court candidates.

And guess what? The party shoehorned two lawyers onto the bench without any screening. Kenny Sherman, son of district leader Roberta Sherman, will get a 10-year Civil Court term without so much as a primary. And Canarsie Assemblyman Frank Seddio was awarded an uncontested ballot line for Surrogate's Court. So much for quality control. So much for keeping your word.

Daily News (quoted from "It Takes a Blogger")

Who's online

There are currently 3 users and 1091 guests online.

Blogroll

Editors and Contributors

Mole's Progressive Democrat
Alien and Sedition
Dan Jacoby

The Indies

Adirondack Musings
The Albany Project
Angry Brown Butch
Atlantic Yards Report
Blue Spot
Buffalo Pundit
Buffalo Geek
Bike Blog
Brooklyn Rail
The Community Alliance
Danger Democrat
DDDB
DragonFlyEye
EverythingNY
Gowanus Lounge
Hell's Kitchen Online
Joshing Politics
Mamita Mala
Mamapalooza blog
More Gardens
Nassau GOP Watch
New York Games
No Land Grab
NY 13
On NY Turf
Peter King Watch
Politics on the Hudson
Open Orleans
Prometheus6
Room Eight
Steve Gilliard RIP
The Oil Drum
Troy Polloi
Rochester Turning
Simply Left Behind
Time's Up
The Working Families Party Man
Power from Truth by Chris Owens

The little big media

Capitol Confidential
Gotham Gazette
Daily Politics
Wonkster
New York Blade
NYC Bloggers
NYC Indymedia
The Politicker
EmpireZone
Power Plays
Spin Cycle

The big little media

Curbed
Gawker
Gothamist
The Politico
City Limits

Everybody Party! blogs

New Democratic Majority
Stonewall Democrats
Working Families Party's WFPBlog

The Brains

The Brennan Center
Reform NY
The Century Foundation
Center for American Progress
Drum Major Institute's DMIblog
edwize
TortDeform

The Movement

New Democratic Majority
Democracy for NYC
DL21C
Act Now
Capitol D Group
New York Democratic Lawyers Council

The Loyal Opposition

Alarming News
News Copy
Ragged Thots
Suitably Flip
Urban Elephants
Serf City

Fun Stuff

City Rag
Jossip
Overheard in New York
Cobalt 6

This list is a work in progress. Are there blogs you believe should be included (maybe your own)? Please leaves us a message through our contact page. Or drop us a line at :

editors(at)
dailygotham(dot)com


Progressive Districts

Progressive States

Alabama
Arizona
California Colorado
Connecticut
Delaware
Florida
Georgia
Hawaii
Idaho
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Louisiana
Maine
Maryland
Massachusetts
Michigan
Minnesota
Mississippi
Missouri
Montana
Nebraska
Nevada
New Hampshire
New Jersey
New Mexico
New York
New York
North Carolina
North Dakota
Ohio
Ohio
Oklahoma
Oregon
Pennsylvania
Rhode Island
South Dakota
Tennessee
Texas
Texas
Utah
Vermont
Virginia
Washington
West Virginia
Wisconsin
Pacific Northwest
Sunbelt