Battling Op-Eds

The battle over Eliot Spitzer's executive order to give New York State ID cards to applicants without a social security number is escalating across the Op-Ed pages of the state.

New York Daily News:

Ruben Diaz, the Democratic state senator and Pentecostal minister from the Bronx, calls it the "worst display of racism" he's seen since his days as a young soldier in South Carolina in 1960.[...]

At least three of those who spoke at the Senate hearing are connected with the Federation for American Immigration Reform, which has been spearheading legislation against legal and illegal immigration.

FAIR's founder and longtime leader John Tanton is perhaps the biggest nativist in the U.S. today and an open proponent of population control.

In the 1980s and 1990s, Tanton's FAIR received more than $1million in funding from the Pioneer Fund, an organization dedicated to promoting eugenics and "race betterment." The Pioneer Fund's leaders have even advocated sterilization of the "feeble-minded."

Tom Tancredo, the Republican congressman from Colorado who is running for President, testified against the Spitzer license policy at an Oct. 3 Republican Assembly hearing in Albany.

Tancredo told the Denver Post in July 2005 that immigrants "are coming here to kill you, and you, and me and my grandchildren."

He has also said: "There are places right now in East L.A. and southern Texas ... there is absolutely nothing you would say that makes them part of the United States of America."

These are the kind of people that Republicans in Albany called in as "experts" to testify about Spitzer's license policy.

The Albany Times-Union:

The governor's hell-bent pursuit of an unneeded rule change that would allow illegal immigrants to get New York state driver's licenses is bad public policy and worse politics, and the intensity of the argument over his unprompted decision it is not diminishing.

The horrendous political implications are obvious when nearly three-quarters of the electorate are against it, and emotionally so.

No matter how the issue turns out in the short run, Spitzer will rue the day he threw this piece of raw meat into the arena.

Probably the savvy lawyers in Spitzer's camp can find a way to ram this rule change through, regardless of opposition legislation from the Senate and growing public hubbub. But this arrogant imposition against the will of the people will continue to fester and have a long life, right to the next election.

Nice. Now that words like racist and arrogant are being thrown around, and that we've established that immigrants are here to kill us or, alternatively, that we're back to Jim Crow - somewhat rich coming from Ruben Diaz - I'm sure we'll see an amicable resolution soon that works in the best interests of the state. Watch those upcoming local elections, folks; there may be a surprise or two in store for all of us.

Bouldin's picture

|

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
TerryONeillEsq's picture

Drivergate

Governor Eliot Spitzer is coming across as a most unreasonable man, a character trait most recently on display in what columnist Fred LeBrun of the Albany Times Union calls "Drivergate".

Well, the governor is in good company.

Those who knew the late and extraordinarily effective Governor Nelson A. Rockefeller well use that very word -- unreasonable -- to describe his personality and his approach to pursuing an agenda he deemed in the public interest. His enduring record of achievement speaks for itself and what it says is not an apology. While he never styled himself a "steamroller", Rocky is memorably the only Vice President in the history of the United States who was photographed "flipping the bird" at his critics.

With the "Drivergate” controversy, Governor Spitzer is learning something about Albany that I learned back in the Cuomo administration.

Dealing with the crowd of politicians and bureaucrats in this town -- the people who who have earned Albany its infamous reputation as the most dysfuntional state government in the nation -- is like going up to Saratoga for a day at the races with a group of acquaintances.

We all go out to the stables to look over the horses. I point one out and say: “That’s a winner. Let’s bet on it.“ My companions all disagree and en masse put their money on another horse.

The race is run. My horse comes in first. Theirs comes in second or third or wherever. But it does, at lleast, reach the finish line.

Over the course of the afternoon, we repeat this process several times. Each time, I pick a winner and they all bet on a loser.

Finally, in exasperation, I say, while displaying my fistfull of dollars: “As you can see, I consistently pick winners. Why won’t you bet on my picks and win some money?”

“Because you’re not a team player. And you’re a threat.”

The anti-Spitzer vitriol that is spewing and gushing so copiously here in Albany certainly indicates that our governor is a threat. A threat to that infamously dysfunctional status quo in state government with which all the other bettors are quite comfortable.

Drivergate? Well, the fact is that New York has a huge population of illegal immigrants that raises significant public security issues ranging from traffic safety to organized crime and terrorism. The governor is responsible for these problems. He is taking a very minor but sensible administrative step to address at least one of them. If nothing else, he has brought huge attention -- even that of Michael Chertoff -- to this problem. There may be those — even a majority — who think he’s on the wrong track, but he’s riding a winning horse. And what would those critics say if something terrible happened and the governor had not taken at least the action he has proposed?

Personally, as a long-time student of public security policy, I’m more concerned about the percentage of our illegal immigrant population that is involved in organized crime, trafficking in drugs and other contraband, including human beings, and violent gang activity. And let’s not forget all of the law-abiding among the people in that shadowy world of illegal status who are victimized and exploited by those who are also here illegally and up to no good.

Permit me to toss out this idea: Let's consider, while we are awaiting federal action on immigration policy and for the bugs to be worked out of DMV’s document authentication technology, that when these people come in to apply for a driver’s license, we take their fingerprints and add them to the database at the Division of Criminal Justice Services for the standard fee, of course. At least then, we can track them down if they commit a crime.

Now that’s my pick for a winning horse.

brought to you by


Current weather

NY - New York City, Central Park

night-few
  • Few clouds
  • Temperature: 37.4 °F
  • Wind: Variable from South to Northwest, 11.5 mph, gusts up to 27.6 mph
  • Pressure: 29.24 inHg
  • Rel. Humidity: 65%
  • Visibility: 10 miles

Premium Advertisers


Fill up our coffee cup fund!






Visit Our Sponsors


Subscribe to our daily digest

In keeping with the "city that never sleeps" tradition, keep up to date with our daily syndication digest.



Powered by FeedBlitz


culturekitchen Media

The Publisher
Liza Sabater

Fresh dissent served daily
culturekitchen

Grassroots News and
Activism for New Yorkers

Daily Gotham

Feminist Bloggers Network
BlogSheroes

A new kind of voyeurism
Voogling

Art + Code + Philosophy
Potatoland.blog

Got any dirt, tips, leads or money for us? Then drop us a line or two at editors [at] dailygotham [dot] com or use our general contact form to reach everybody in the editorial team ASAP.


Only in New York

Jesus Christ was a Community Organizer
Pontius Pilate was a Governor

— From a political button

Who's online

There are currently 4 users and 1403 guests online.

Blogroll

Editors and Contributors

Mole's Progressive Democrat
Alien and Sedition
Dan Jacoby

The Indies

Adirondack Musings
The Albany Project
Angry Brown Butch
Atlantic Yards Report
Blue Spot
Buffalo Pundit
Buffalo Geek
Bike Blog
Brooklyn Rail
The Community Alliance
Danger Democrat
DDDB
DragonFlyEye
EverythingNY
Gowanus Lounge
Hell's Kitchen Online
Joshing Politics
Mamita Mala
Mamapalooza blog
More Gardens
Nassau GOP Watch
New York Games
No Land Grab
NY 13
On NY Turf
Peter King Watch
Politics on the Hudson
Open Orleans
Prometheus6
Room Eight
Steve Gilliard RIP
The Oil Drum
Troy Polloi
Rochester Turning
Simply Left Behind
Time's Up
The Working Families Party Man
Power from Truth by Chris Owens

The little big media

Capitol Confidential
Gotham Gazette
Daily Politics
Wonkster
New York Blade
NYC Bloggers
NYC Indymedia
The Politicker
EmpireZone
Power Plays
Spin Cycle

The big little media

Curbed
Gawker
Gothamist
The Politico
City Limits

Everybody Party! blogs

New Democratic Majority
Stonewall Democrats
Working Families Party's WFPBlog

The Brains

The Brennan Center
Reform NY
The Century Foundation
Center for American Progress
Drum Major Institute's DMIblog
edwize
TortDeform

The Movement

New Democratic Majority
Democracy for NYC
DL21C
Act Now
Capitol D Group
New York Democratic Lawyers Council

The Loyal Opposition

Alarming News
News Copy
Ragged Thots
Suitably Flip
Urban Elephants
Serf City

Fun Stuff

City Rag
Jossip
Overheard in New York
Cobalt 6

This list is a work in progress. Are there blogs you believe should be included (maybe your own)? Please leaves us a message through our contact page. Or drop us a line at :

editors(at)
dailygotham(dot)com


Progressive Districts

Progressive States

Alabama
Arizona
California Colorado
Connecticut
Delaware
Florida
Georgia
Hawaii
Idaho
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Louisiana
Maine
Maryland
Massachusetts
Michigan
Minnesota
Mississippi
Missouri
Montana
Nebraska
Nevada
New Hampshire
New Jersey
New Mexico
New York
New York
North Carolina
North Dakota
Ohio
Ohio
Oklahoma
Oregon
Pennsylvania
Rhode Island
South Dakota
Tennessee
Texas
Texas
Utah
Vermont
Virginia
Washington
West Virginia
Wisconsin
Pacific Northwest
Sunbelt