Search
Chaos on the Hill, uproar at the base
Twenty years ago today, the hated Wall of Berlin came thundering down under the hammers of a long-suffering people denied their freedom and their basic dignity by the communist tyranny of East Germany.
A year and some days ago, America astonished the world by drawing a bright blue line under the hateful Bush era, with the election of a new, young Democratic President, Barack Obama, and equipping him with almost unprecedented majorities in both chambers of the national legislature. Calls for change echoed around the nation, tearing down ancient prejudices and long-held assumptions in their wake. Everything was possible in the new, shining moment, the shining city on a hill restored to its full luster.
And as twenty years ago, the uprising in the United States was built on the will and the power of a people that had had enough.
Today the Congress is debating one of the great challenges facing the country, health care, and it's muck. Republicans and anti-choice Democrats will vote on a poison pill amendment to the main, must-pass bill that bars insurance for abortions, which is a complete tragedy.
From the left, netroots superstar Eric Massa declared that he could not support the main bill that is now making its way to the floor of the House. All other members of the New York Democratic delegation, including newcomer Bill Owens - who prevailed in NY-23, hahaha, despite Sarah Palin's orders to the contrary - are expected to vote for the healthcare bill see update and expect a roll call after the vote. Yes, we'll be keeping score.
The day before the much-anticipated vote on health care reform in the House of Representatives, Eric Massa, D-Corning, said that the Affordable Health Care for America Act gives too much to the insurance industry, doesn’t do enough to control costs, and he can’t support it.
“At the highest level this bill will enshrine in law the monopolistic powers of the private health insurance industry,” Massa said in a telephone news conference this morning. “There’s no other way to look at it.”
Massa said that the bill “fails to address the fundamental question before the American people, and that is, how do you control the costs of health care?”
Congressman Massa is correct when he argues that the current House bill creates a system that is glaringly inferior to the ideal solution, a single-payer approach that at a slice of the scalpel removes layers upon layers of bureaucracy, expenses, lobbyists, advertising budgets and what not other expenses that lard up U.S. health care spending with a cool $350 billion a year. But if that's your position, please, Sir, show us the votes in the House and the Senate, and how exactly you're going to get them.
And please don't expect a single netroots dollar for your next campaign.
Update: Spoke too soon. McMahon of Staten Island is voting against, Patrick Murphy of NY-20 is undecided.




Re: Chaos on the Hill, uproar at the base
Massa is not the lone member of the New York Delegation to vote NO on the Health Care Bill. Add the name of Mike McMahon of CD-13 (Staten Island and Brooklyn) to that list.
http://www.silive.com/news/index.ssf/2009/11/mcmahon_will_vote_against_h...
I called McMahon's DC Office today and was told that he's voting NO because of deductions to Medicare. When I asked why the AARP would endorse this bill if there was money removed from Medicare I couldn't get a direct answer.
The birthers and deathers brought into his Town Hall on Staten Island have cowered McMahon into voting against this bill. The very people who won't vote for him anyway (and most of which were BUSSED INTO THE MEETING FROM OUT OF THE DISTRICT) because he's a Dem have now caused him to ignore the many in his district that have been asking him to vote in favor of this bill. At the Brooklyn Town Hall at least 99.8% ASKED HIM TO VOTE IN FAVOR OF THIS BILL, yet he ignored us.
To Congressman McMahon I want to say, you've lost my vote and that of at least 75 others from your district that I know. We will NOT contribute one penny to your re-election next year. When you ask for volunteers to help you, look elsewhere, because we won't be there. With your endorsement of Bloomberg and now this disgraceful vote, I want to know why you have not yet crossed over and joined the Republican Party. You call yourself a Democrate well Congressman McMahon, I call you a DINO. You're no better than our previous Congressman - Vito Fossella so look elsewhere for support and contributions in 2010.
Re: Chaos on the Hill, uproar at the base
Patrick Murphy is a second-term congressman representing PA-08 (suburban Philadelphia). He voted against Stupak-Pitts, and is a solid vote on health care reform in general. NY-20 is represented by *Scott* Murphy.
The greater Northeast is also home to Tim Murphy (R-PA18) and Chris Murphy (D-CT05), whose district borders Scott's.